Five Guys Milkshake Menu: Flavors, Nutrition & More
Five Guys started serving milkshakes in 2014. This was a big change from their original focus on burgers and fries. The milkshakes are made with a vanilla base that’s hand-spun for a smooth taste.
This base lets you add your favorite mix-ins. You can choose from fruit, candy, cookies, and even bacon. It’s all about making your shake your own.
The milkshake menu at Five Guys is all about being creative and indulgent. Each shake is one size and has a rich base. This base has about 670 calories, 32 g of fat, and 13 g of protein before you add any mix-ins.
Adding whipped cream is a popular choice. It adds about 20 calories to your shake. This makes your milkshake even creamier and more delicious.
When ordering, keep in mind that milkshakes are only sold in one size. You might want to share or save half to eat less. This guide will help you pick the right milkshake flavors and options. You can choose based on taste and what’s good for you.
Overview of the Five Guys Milkshake Menu
Five Guys added milkshakes to their menu in 2014. They wanted to offer a dessert that felt handcrafted, alongside their famous burgers and fries. Now, many people visit Five Guys just for the milkshakes.
Every milkshake starts with a vanilla base that’s hand-spun. Team members blend in mix-ins until it’s thick and smooth. You can also add whipped cream on top.
Customization is key at Five Guys. You can choose from up to ten mix-ins at U.S. locations. This lets you create unique milkshakes, from fruity to candy-like.
The mix-ins add texture to the shakes. You might find crunchy bacon next to soft cookie bits. This mix of textures and flavors makes each milkshake special.
| Item Name | Description | Calories | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vanilla Base Shake | Classic hand-spun vanilla, ready for mix-ins | 700 | $4.99 |
| Chocolate Mix | Vanilla base blended with rich chocolate syrup | 820 | $5.49 |
| Strawberry Mix | Vanilla base with real strawberry pieces | 760 | $5.49 |
| Oreo Mix | Crushed Oreo cookies folded into the shake | 880 | $5.99 |
| Peanut Butter Cup | Chopped peanut butter cups mixed into vanilla | 950 | $6.29 |
| Bacon Shake | Salty-sweet with crisp bacon bits | 930 | $6.29 |
| Banana Blend | Fresh banana slices blended with vanilla | 770 | $5.49 |
| M&M Mix | Colorful candy pieces for crunch and sweetness | 900 | $5.99 |
| Salted Caramel | Caramel swirls and a hint of sea salt | 860 | $5.99 |
| Coffee Shake | Espresso-infused base for a coffee kick | 780 | $5.79 |
| Items | Vegan | Keto-Friendly | Gluten-Free |
| Vanilla Base Shake | No | No | No |
| Chocolate Mix | No | No | No |
| Strawberry Mix | No | No | No |
| Oreo Mix | No | No | No |
| Peanut Butter Cup | No | No | No |
| Bacon Shake | No | No | No |
| Banana Blend | No | No | No |
| M&M Mix | No | No | No |
| Salted Caramel | No | No | No |
| Coffee Shake | No | No | No |
| Items | Allergens | Allergens | Allergens |
| Vanilla Base Shake | Dairy | Nuts (cross-contact possible) | Gluten (cross-contact) |
| Chocolate Mix | Dairy, Soy | Tree Nuts (possible) | Gluten (cross-contact) |
| Strawberry Mix | Dairy | None typical | Gluten (cross-contact) |
| Oreo Mix | Dairy, Wheat | Contains Wheat | Contains Wheat |
| Peanut Butter Cup | Dairy, Peanuts | Peanuts | Gluten (cross-contact) |
| Bacon Shake | Dairy | None typical | Gluten (cross-contact) |
| Banana Blend | Dairy | None typical | Gluten (cross-contact) |
| M&M Mix | Dairy | Tree Nuts (possible) | Gluten (cross-contact) |
| Salted Caramel | Dairy | None typical | Gluten (cross-contact) |
| Coffee Shake | Dairy | None typical | Gluten (cross-contact) |
Expect big portions when you order a milkshake. Many people share one to keep calories in check. This is because the shakes are rich and topped with generous ingredients.
When you order, tell them what mix-ins you want. The hand-spun method and customization options make Five Guys’ milkshakes a hit. If you love bold flavors and textures, you’ll find something perfect here.
five guys milkshake menu
Five Guys keeps its milkshake options simple and flexible. You get a single-size shake made from a vanilla base with a choice of mix-ins blended in. Customers choose classic and candy-forward additions, plus fruit and savory touches that change taste and texture.
List of standard mix-ins available in US locations
U.S. locations typically offer ten standard mix-ins. These items form the core of milkshake mix-ins at Five Guys and are available year-round in most restaurants.
- Chocolate
- Peanut butter
- Bacon
- Oreo cookies
- Oreo crème
- Strawberry
- Banana
- Reese’s Cups
- Salted caramel
- Vanilla (listed as a mix-in though it is the base)
| Item Name | Description | Calories | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chocolate | Rich chocolate blended into the vanilla base for a smooth cocoa finish. | +130 cal | $0.75–$1.25 |
| Peanut Butter | Creamy peanut butter for a dense, nutty flavor and thicker mouthfeel. | +320 cal | $0.75–$1.50 |
| Bacon | Cooked bacon bits folded in for salty crunch and savory contrast. | +70 cal | $1.00–$1.50 |
| Oreo Cookies | Crushed Oreo pieces for chewy-crumb texture and chocolate cookie bites. | +120 cal | $0.75–$1.25 |
| Oreo Crème | Smooth crème filling swirled in for extra sweetness and creaminess. | +320 cal | $0.75–$1.25 |
| Strawberry | Fresh-styled strawberry preparation for bright, fruity notes. | +90 cal | $0.75–$1.25 |
| Banana | Mashed banana folded in for natural sweetness and soft texture. | +160 cal | $0.75–$1.25 |
| Reese’s Cups | Chopped peanut butter cups for candy pieces and chocolate-peanut contrast. | +150 cal | $0.75–$1.50 |
| Salted Caramel | Sweet-and-salty caramel ribbons for buttery, sticky sweetness. | +155 cal | $0.75–$1.50 |
| Vanilla | Extra vanilla for a stronger classic profile atop the base flavor. | Variable | $0.00–$0.75 |
Typical ordering options and add-ons
Five Guys sells a single-size shake only. You can request any combination of the standard mix-ins. Staff blend mix-ins into the shake, creating uniform texture or chunks depending on items chosen.
Whipped cream is a common add-on and adds about 20 calories. Customers often ask for “everything” to test the limits of milkshake toppings. Locations may accept special requests for texture and mix density.
| Items | Vegan | Keto-Friendly | Gluten-Free | Allergens (Nuts, Dairy, etc.) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chocolate | No | No | Depends on product | Dairy |
| Peanut Butter | No | No | Yes | Nuts, Dairy |
| Bacon | No | Possible | Yes | None typical, cross-contact possible |
| Oreo Cookies | No | No | No | Wheat, Dairy |
| Oreo Crème | No | No | No | Dairy, Soy |
| Strawberry | Yes | No | Yes | None typical, cross-contact possible |
| Banana | Yes | No | Yes | None typical |
| Reese’s Cups | No | No | No | Nuts, Dairy |
| Salted Caramel | No | No | Depends on product | Dairy |
| Vanilla | No | No | Depends on product | Dairy |
Seasonal mix-ins may appear at select locations. If you want a smaller portion, consider splitting a single shake to share. Asking staff about current milkshake toppings lets you spot limited releases or regional variations.
Popular milkshake flavors and recommended combos
Five Guys milkshake menu favorites mix classic sweets with fun textures. This section shows the top milkshake flavors and combos that people love. You’ll find short descriptions to help you choose a favorite or create your own.
Top-rated combinations from crowdsourced and editorial rankings
Rankings show that peanut butter-based mixes are favorites. The most loved combos include peanut butter with banana and bacon, a mix of all available ingredients, and strawberry plus banana.
| Rank | Item Name | Description | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Peanut Butter + Banana + Bacon | Elvis-style mix: bold peanut butter, ripe banana, crispy bacon bites for sweet-salty balance. | ~900 |
| 2 | Everything | All mix-ins combined for maximum variety and texture. Rich and very filling; great to share. | ~1200 |
| 3 | Strawberry + Banana | Fresh strawberry brightness meets creamy banana for a smooth, fruity shake. | ~700 |
| 4 | Vanilla + Peanut Butter + Banana | Classic trio that highlights peanut butter while banana adds body and sweetness. | ~800 |
| 5 | Peanut Butter + Bacon + Oreo | Crunchy Oreo with salty bacon and peanut butter creates a bold texture play. | ~950 |
| 6 | Strawberry + Oreo | Fruity notes balanced by cookie cocoa pieces for a pleasant contrast. | ~780 |
| 7 | Peanut Butter + Reese’s Cups | Extra candy chunks boost peanut-butter intensity and add chewy texture. | ~980 |
| 8 | Peanut Butter + Bacon + Salted Caramel | Salted caramel softens the bacon edge and lifts peanut butter with sweet-salty notes. | ~1020 |
| 9 | Peanut Butter + Salted Caramel + Chocolate | Layered sweetness where caramel and chocolate round out the peanut profile. | ~990 |
| 10 | Chocolate + Strawberry | Traditional pairing: chocolate bits with bright strawberry for a familiar dessert-like shake. | ~820 |
Balanced fruity blends
Fruity blends focus on bright, clean flavors. Strawberry + Banana is a top choice for its smooth mouthfeel and clear fruit taste.
Strawberry + Oreo mixes fruit brightness with cocoa crunch. This combo keeps the flavor lively without making the vanilla base too heavy.
Chocolate-forward and candy-style blends
Chocolate-forward shakes on the five guys milkshake menu are milky and sweet. Chocolate + Strawberry is a crowd-pleaser for its dessert-like taste.
Peanut Butter + Reese’s and peanut butter with candy pieces offer strong peanut flavor with chunky texture. Adding salted caramel brings a sweet-salty lift that pairs well with chocolate or peanut butter.
- Tip: The “Everything” option gives wide taste variety. It can overwhelm a single diner; sharing is sensible.
- Tip: Peanut butter acts as a dominant base. Pair with banana to maintain balance and prevent the vanilla base from tasting thin.
Milkshake mix-ins explained: taste, texture, and pairing tips
At Five Guys, mix-ins are key to making creamy milkshakes. They balance flavor and texture perfectly. This guide helps you pick the right mix-ins and toppings from the five guys milkshake menu.
Fresh fruit mix-ins
Five Guys uses fresh fruit to keep the texture bright. Strawberries are mixed with a bit of simple syrup, lemon, salt, and pepper. This enhances their natural sweetness. Bananas are mixed with syrup and salt to blend smoothly, making the milkshakes richer.
Fruit adds a light, juicy taste that pairs well with vanilla or peanut butter. Try banana with peanut butter for a rich flavor. Or strawberry with vanilla for a classic taste.
Cookie and candy mix-ins
Oreo pieces add a black-cocoa bite and a sandy texture. Oreo creme makes the mix sweeter and creamier. Reese’s Cups bring a peanut-butter flavor and a chunky texture that contrasts well with softer bases.
Chocolate mix-ins offer a milky chocolate taste, not intense dark cocoa. Candy and cookie mix-ins add texture. Pair them with fruit or peanut butter to balance the richness.
Savory and specialty mix-ins
Bacon is cooked crisp and added as crunchy crumbles. It adds smoky-salty notes in every bite. Salted caramel adds a toasted sugar depth that matches chocolate or peanut butter well.
Peanut butter is dense and can dominate the flavor. Balance it with banana, bacon, or a cookie for contrast. Use salty mix-ins sparingly to balance sweetness while keeping the shake approachable.
| Item Name | Description | Calories | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Strawberry | Fresh strawberries in light syrup; bright and slightly tart | 150 | $1.25 |
| Banana | Ripe banana purée with simple syrup; adds creaminess | 120 | $1.25 |
| Oreo | Crushed sandwich cookies for cocoa crunch | 180 | $1.50 |
| Reese’s Cups | Chopped peanut-butter cups with chocolate bits | 210 | $1.75 |
| Chocolate | Milk chocolate blend for smooth cocoa flavor | 140 | $1.00 |
| Bacon | Crispy bacon crumbles for smoky-salty contrast | 90 | $1.50 |
| Salted Caramel | Toasted sugar syrup with a pinch of salt | 160 | $1.50 |
| Peanut Butter | Thick, creamy peanut butter for dense flavor | 200 | $1.50 |
| Oreo Creme | Sweeter, creamy cookie filling option | 170 | $1.50 |
| Mixed Fruit Blend | Seasonal mix for varied sweetness and texture | 140 | $1.75 |
| Items | Vegan | Keto-Friendly | Gluten-Free | Allergens |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Strawberry | No | No | Yes | Dairy |
| Banana | No | No | Yes | Dairy |
| Oreo | No | No | No | Wheat, Dairy |
| Reese’s Cups | No | No | No | Peanuts, Dairy |
| Chocolate | No | No | Yes | Dairy |
| Bacon | No | Yes (limited) | Yes | None |
| Salted Caramel | No | No | Yes | Dairy |
| Peanut Butter | No | No | Yes | Peanuts, Dairy |
| Oreo Creme | No | No | No | Dairy, Wheat |
| Mixed Fruit Blend | No | No | Yes | Dairy |
Pairing tips
Use banana to anchor peanut butter blends for a creamy profile. Add bacon sparingly to sweet combos for a smoky contrast. Combine cookies with fruit, like strawberry + Oreo, for crunch and freshness.
To control sweetness, match salty mix-ins like bacon or salted caramel with vanilla or fruit. When building from the five guys milkshake menu, pick one dominant flavor and one textural mix-in. This keeps each shake balanced and enjoyable.
Nutrition facts for Five Guys milkshakes and mix-ins
The Five Guys milkshake base is always the same size. It has about 670 calories, 32 g of fat, and 13 g of protein. This amount is the same for every standard milkshake order.
Here’s a quick guide to common mix-ins and their calories. It helps you estimate the total calories before you order. Or, it’s useful for planning to share.
| Item Name | Description | Calories | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whipped Cream | Light dollop topping | 20 | $0.50 |
| Bacon | Savory, crisp pieces | 70 | $1.00 |
| Strawberry | Fresh fruit blend | 90 | $1.00 |
| Banana | Mashed banana swirls | 160 | $1.25 |
| Peanut Butter | Rich, nutty ribbon | 320 | $1.50 |
| Reese’s Cups | Chopped candy pieces | 150 | $1.50 |
| Chocolate | Cocoa syrup and bits | 130 | $1.00 |
| Oreo Creme | Oreo creme swirls | 320 | $1.50 |
| Oreo Cookies | Crushed cookies | 120 | $1.25 |
| Salted Caramel | Sweet-salty ribbon | 155 | $1.25 |
Adding mix-ins quickly increases the calories in your milkshake. For example, adding peanut butter and whipped cream can make it over 1,000 calories. A mix with peanut butter and Oreo Creme can be near or over 1,500 calories, depending on how much you add.
As you add ingredients, the nutrition of your milkshake changes. The base gives most of the fat and protein. But, mix-ins like peanut butter and Oreo Creme add a lot of fat and carbs. Fruit mix-ins, on the other hand, increase carbs and add natural sugars while keeping fat lower.
| Items | Vegan | Keto-Friendly | Gluten-Free | Allergens |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base (Vanilla) | No | No | No | Dairy |
| Whipped Cream | No | No | Yes | Dairy |
| Bacon | No | Depends | Yes | None (pork) |
| Strawberry | Yes | No | Yes | None |
| Banana | Yes | No | Yes | None |
| Peanut Butter | Yes | No | Yes | Nuts, Possible Cross-Contact |
| Reese’s Cups | No | No | No | Peanut, Dairy |
| Chocolate | Some | No | Depends | Dairy, Soy |
| Oreo Creme | No | No | No | Wheat, Dairy |
| Oreo Cookies | No | No | No | Wheat, Soy |
| Salted Caramel | No | No | Depends | Dairy |
When thinking about milkshake nutrition, remember that Five Guys is known for big portions. This is true for their burgers and fries, and it’s also true for their shakes. Being aware of the calories in milkshakes is good advice for enjoying them occasionally.
To keep your calorie intake in check, consider sharing your shake or choosing a lower-calorie mix-in. Tracking the macros in your milkshake helps you balance it with the rest of your day. The Five Guys milkshake menu offers clear choices, so you can pick flavors that fit your preferences and goals.
Healthier ordering tips and portion guidance
Milkshakes at Five Guys are a treat best enjoyed with a simple plan. The Five Guys milkshake menu lists a single standard size. Use sharing, saving, and smart mix-in choices to control intake. Small swaps and order notes can cut calories without dulling flavor.
How to reduce calories and manage portions
Start with a base shake around 670 calories. Split the cup with a friend or save half for later to halve milkshake calories instantly. Ask for no whipped cream to shave off roughly 20 calories.
Pick fruit mix-ins like strawberry (+90) or banana (+160) instead of high-calorie add-ons such as peanut butter (+320) or Oreo creme (+320).
Request fewer mix-ins or choose one flavor instead of multiple. If sharing is not possible, plan a lighter meal earlier or later in the day to keep total daily intake balanced.
Contextual nutrition advice
Treat milkshakes as occasional indulgences and track them alongside meals. Add mix-in calories to the 670-calorie base to estimate totals before ordering. For example, a base plus strawberry and banana is far lower in milkshake calories than a base with peanut butter and Oreo creme.
When counting macros, swap a full burger for a Little burger or skip fries to offset the extra calories. Use portion guidance as a tool to fit a shake into an active lifestyle without overshooting daily goals.
Dietary considerations
Milkshakes contain dairy and are not vegan. Most mix-ins include gluten or dairy, so people with celiac disease or lactose intolerance should choose carefully. Peanut butter and some candies pose nut-allergy risks. Bacon and pork-based add-ons conflict with certain diets.
Keto followers should avoid shakes because of high carbs and sugars; bunless burgers offer a lower-carb choice at Five Guys. For gluten-free needs, verify cookie-based mix-ins—Oreo contains wheat. Always ask staff about cross-contact and ingredient details before ordering.
| Item Name | Description | Calories | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vanilla (base) | Classic creamy base, neutral flavor for mix-ins | 670 | $4.99 |
| Strawberry mix-in | Fresh-tasting fruit addition, bright and sweet | +90 | $0.75 |
| Banana mix-in | Soft, natural sweetness that pairs well with chocolate | +160 | $0.75 |
| Peanut Butter mix-in | Rich and salty, strong nut flavor | +320 | $0.99 |
| Oreo creme mix-in | Cookie crunch and sweet creme swirls | +320 | $0.99 |
| Chocolate mix-in | Deep cocoa taste, works with many combos | +120 | $0.75 |
| Butterscotch mix-in | Caramel-like richness, buttery finish | +150 | $0.75 |
| Malt | Classic malted milk flavor for depth | +110 | $0.75 |
| Chocolate chip cookie | Crunchy cookie pieces, sweet texture contrast | +200 | $0.99 |
| Candy pieces | Assorted candy bits for extra sweetness | +210 | $0.99 |
| Items | Vegan | Keto-Friendly | Gluten-Free | Allergens (Nuts, Dairy, etc.) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vanilla base | No | No | No | Dairy |
| Strawberry mix-in | No | No | Yes | Dairy |
| Banana mix-in | No | No | Yes | Dairy |
| Peanut Butter mix-in | No | No | No | Nuts, Dairy |
| Oreo creme mix-in | No | No | No | Wheat, Dairy |
| Chocolate mix-in | No | No | Depends | Dairy, Soy |
| Butterscotch mix-in | No | No | Depends | Dairy |
| Malt | No | No | No | Dairy, Gluten |
| Chocolate chip cookie | No | No | No | Wheat, Dairy |
| Candy pieces | No | No | Depends | Dairy, Nuts (varies) |
- Ask staff about seasonal mix-ins and allergen handling before ordering.
- Share or save part of your shake to manage portion guidance effectively.
- Choose fruit-based mix-ins when cutting milkshake calories matters most.
Pricing and value: what to expect for a Five Guys milkshake
Five Guys offers a single, generous milkshake size across most U.S. locations. The one-size approach keeps ordering simple and gives you unlimited mix-ins for the listed price. This makes customers think about milkshake prices and the value of shakes at Five Guys.
Single-size pricing structure
The cost of milkshake varies by city and state because local taxes and operating costs change sticker prices. Expect a single price for any number of mix-ins, whether you choose classic chocolate or multiple candy and fruit additions. This makes the five guys milkshake menu straightforward: one size, one base price, unlimited customization.
| Item Name | Description | Calories | Price (typical range) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vanilla (base) | Creamy hand-spun vanilla shake, customizable with mix-ins | 700–900 | $4.50–$6.50 |
| Chocolate | Rich chocolate shake, made to order with fresh mix-ins | 750–950 | $4.75–$6.75 |
| Strawberry | Fresh fruit-forward shake using blended strawberries | 720–920 | $4.75–$6.75 |
| Bacon | Sweet and salty with crisp bacon pieces folded in | 800–1000 | $5.00–$7.00 |
| Oreo mix-in | Chunks of Oreo cookies blended into the shake | 850–1050 | $5.00–$7.00 |
| Peanut Butter | Velvety peanut butter combined with ice cream base | 900–1100 | $5.25–$7.25 |
| Malted | Malted flavor added for a classic diner taste | 760–960 | $4.75–$6.75 |
| Banana | Fresh banana slices mixed in for natural sweetness | 730–930 | $4.75–$6.75 |
| Chocolate + Candy combo | Signature candy pieces blended with chocolate base | 900–1200 | $5.25–$7.50 |
| Custom mix-in | Any combination of available mix-ins at one price | Varies | $4.50–$7.50 |
Cost versus portion and sharing strategy
The single serving is large and calorie-dense. Splitting a shake between two people lowers the cost-per-ounce and spreads calories. Many guests choose to share or save half for later to improve value and manage intake.
Choosing the base shake without extras keeps the cost of milkshake at the lower end of local ranges. Fewer mix-ins cut calories without reducing price, so think of customization as a value choice.
Comparing cost to other fast-food shakes
Price comparisons depend on the market. Five Guys milkshake prices can be slightly higher than quick-serve counterparts at chains like McDonald’s or Dairy Queen. The difference lies in preparation style: Five Guys hand-spins shakes and folds in fresh or whole mix-ins on request.
This hands-on method contributes to the perceived higher value of shakes for customers who prioritize fresh ingredients and tailored flavors. If you watch local pricing, you can balance taste preferences with budget and find the right trade-off between cost of milkshake and the value of shakes you receive.
- Tip: Check your local menu before ordering to confirm current milkshake prices.
- Tip: Share to stretch a single price across two people without losing flavor.
- Tip: Order base flavor for fewer calories while keeping the same price point.
| Items | Vegan | Keto-Friendly | Gluten-Free | Allergens (Nuts, Dairy, etc.) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vanilla (base) | No | No | Yes (confirm cross-contact) | Dairy |
| Chocolate | No | No | Yes (confirm cross-contact) | Dairy |
| Strawberry | No | No | Yes (confirm cross-contact) | Dairy |
| Banana | No | No | Yes (confirm cross-contact) | Dairy |
| Oreo mix-in | No | No | No | Wheat, Dairy |
| Peanut Butter | No | No | Yes (confirm cross-contact) | Nuts, Dairy |
| Bacon | No | No | Yes (confirm cross-contact) | Dairy |
| Malted | No | No | No | Dairy, Wheat |
| Chocolate + Candy combo | No | No | Varies by candy | May contain Nuts, Dairy, Wheat |
| Custom mix-in | Varies | Varies | Varies | Depends on chosen mix-ins |
- Compare local menus when deciding where to buy a shake.
- Share or save part of a shake to lower cost-per-portion.
- Pick the base for fewer calories while paying the same price.
- Use one or two high-quality mix-ins to get luxury flavor with controlled cost.
How Five Guys prepares and serves milkshakes
Five Guys makes milkshake prep easy and fun to watch. You order at the counter and staff grab a cold cup. They pour a creamy vanilla base, add your mix-ins, and hand it to a team member at the mixer.
Each shake is hand-spun behind the counter. They add chunky mix-ins like cookies or bacon. This way, you get a thick and frosty shake.
Texture and serving notes
Shakes are thick and frosty. The texture changes based on what you choose. Fruit makes it smooth, while candy or cookie pieces add crunch.
Seasonal and limited-time variations
Five Guys sometimes offers special flavors like coffee. These are available for a limited time. The mix-ins are made on site, so what’s available can change.
| Item Name | Description | Calories | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vanilla Classic | Simple vanilla base, smooth and creamy | 720 | $5.29 |
| Chocolate Candy Mix | Vanilla base with chopped chocolate candies for crunch | 890 | $6.19 |
| Strawberry Fruit Blend | Fresh strawberry pieces blended for a fruity finish | 760 | $5.99 |
| Cookies & Cream | Large cookie chunks folded in for texture | 940 | $6.49 |
| Peanut Butter Cup | Peanut butter and candy pieces, rich and chunky | 980 | $6.49 |
| Bacon Shake | Sweet and savory with chopped bacon bits | 880 | $6.29 |
| Coffee Seasonal | Limited-time coffee-flavored base when offered | 770 | $5.99 |
| Oreo Mix | Crushed Oreo pieces for a chocolate cookie profile | 920 | $6.19 |
| Banana Smooth | Banana slices blended for a smooth fruit-forward shake | 740 | $5.99 |
| Custom Combo | Any combination from the five guys milkshake menu | Varies | Varies |
| Items | Vegan | Keto-Friendly | Gluten-Free | Allergens (Nuts, Dairy, etc.) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vanilla Classic | No | No | Yes* | Dairy |
| Chocolate Candy Mix | No | No | Depends on candy | Dairy, Soy, Possible Nuts |
| Strawberry Fruit Blend | No | No | Yes* | Dairy |
| Cookies & Cream | No | No | Depends on cookies | Dairy, Wheat, Soy |
| Peanut Butter Cup | No | No | Depends on candy | Dairy, Peanuts |
| Bacon Shake | No | No | Yes* | Dairy, Pork |
| Coffee Seasonal | No | No | Yes* | Dairy, Caffeine |
| Oreo Mix | No | No | Depends on cookie | Dairy, Wheat, Soy |
| Banana Smooth | No | No | Yes* | Dairy |
| Custom Combo | Depends | Depends | Depends | Varies by mix-ins |
Practical serving tip
Ask for finer chopping if you prefer a smoother shake. Drink it soon after it’s made for the best experience. If it settles, ask staff to stir it again.
- Ask for mix-in size preference when ordering.
- Use the supplied wide straw for thick blends.
- Check local stores for limited-time items on the five guys milkshake menu.
User favorites and crowd-sourced rankings
Fans share their favorite milkshake flavors at Five Guys. They reveal patterns in taste and texture. These lists show the top milkshake flavors and combos across different areas.
Here’s a quick guide to the most loved drinks. It compares them by flavor, texture, calories, and price. Use it to pick the best milkshake combos to try first.
| Item Name | Description | Calories | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Peanut Butter + Banana + Bacon | Rich peanut butter and sweet banana balanced by crisp, salty bacon. | Approx. 1,200 | $6.99 |
| Peanut Butter + Reese’s Cups | Double peanut richness with chocolate candy bites for texture. | Approx. 1,150 | $6.99 |
| Strawberry + Banana | Fresh fruit forward, creamy and lighter than candy-based shakes. | Approx. 750 | $5.99 |
| Strawberry + Oreo | Fruity base with cookie crunch for a balanced sweet and textured sip. | Approx. 980 | $6.49 |
| Everything / Harmony | All mix-ins combined for max variety and heavy texture contrast. | Approx. 1,400 | $7.49 |
| Chocolate + Reese’s Cups | Chocolate-forward shake with peanut butter candy for extra bite. | Approx. 1,080 | $6.99 |
| Salted Caramel + Oreo | Sweet and salty caramel paired with crunchy cookie pieces. | Approx. 1,020 | $6.49 |
| Vanilla + Fresh Banana | Classic smooth vanilla with fresh fruit for natural sweetness. | Approx. 700 | $5.49 |
| Peanut Butter + Cookie Dough | Thick, chewy bites with creamy peanut backbone. | Approx. 1,200 | $6.99 |
| Chocolate + Bacon | Bold chocolate softened by smoky, salty bacon crunch. | Approx. 1,050 | $6.99 |
These combos are loved for their balance. They mix sweet and salty or crunchy elements. Banana adds creamy sweetness that pairs well with dense mix-ins. Bacon adds a salty, crunchy texture.
Peanut butter is a favorite for its strong, familiar taste. Candy pieces like Reese’s and Oreo add satisfying bites. Combinations that mix sweet, salty, and crunchy are the most popular.
Want to make your own signature shake? Start with a dominant mix-in like peanut butter or Oreo. Add a contrasting element like banana or bacon. Choose fresh fruit for a lighter shake. Save heavy mix-ins for sharing, as they increase calories.
Try the top combos as a starting point. Then, adjust the mix-ins to make it your own. Small changes can make a big difference, from decadent to fruity.
Conclusion
The five guys milkshake menu starts with a 670-calorie vanilla base, introduced in 2014. It’s made to order with about ten standard mix-ins and occasional seasonal ones. You can choose from fresh fruit, cookies, candy, and even bacon for a savory twist.
Milkshake flavors go from bright and fruity to rich and candy-forward. They’re all creamy and sold in one large size. This means calories add up fast with add-ins like peanut butter, Oreo creme, or multiple mix-ins.
For a bold taste, try peanut butter with banana and a bacon sprinkle. For a lighter sweetness, go for fruit blends like strawberry plus banana. To keep portions in check, consider sharing a shake or skipping the heaviest add-ins.
Remember to check local offerings and current prices at your Five Guys. Seasonal mix-ins can change, affecting what’s available.
The menu is all about fun customization and indulgent flavors. Whether you like candy-forward, fruity, or savory-salty, there’s something for everyone. Just remember, the rich base and mix-ins can add up, so plan your portions for a great treat.
